NBC News: Ex-student who alleged sex abuse by monk at elite N.J. Catholic school wins $5M in damages

October 13, 2025

A monumental victory for survivors of abuse has emerged from a New Jersey courtroom, sending a powerful message of hope and accountability across the nation. For decades, countless survivors of childhood sexual abuse have lived in silence, burdened by trauma and the belief that justice was beyond their reach. This week, one man’s courage to speak his truth after half a century resulted in a historic verdict that challenges that silence.

According to a report by Corky Siemaszko for NBC News, "A former student at the elite Delbarton School in New Jersey who said he was sexually assaulted a half-century ago by a monk at the school has been awarded $5 million in damages. The historic verdict in the first civil trial against the Catholic Church in New Jersey was reached by a panel of four women and two men Wednesday after less than two days of deliberation." This outcome is more than just a monetary award; it is a landmark moment in the ongoing fight for justice for survivors of abuse, particularly at the hands of powerful institutions.


A Landmark Case and Its Historic Impact


At Jason J. Joy & Associates, we recognize this verdict as a watershed moment. It is historic not only for being the first civil trial of its kind against the Catholic Church in New Jersey but also for the powerful validation it provides to survivors everywhere. For far too long, institutions have been shielded from accountability, leaving victims to carry the weight of their trauma alone. This $5 million verdict signifies a shift, demonstrating that civil courts can be a powerful avenue for holding responsible parties accountable, even when decades have passed.


Civil lawsuits serve a different, but equally crucial, purpose than criminal trials. While criminal cases aim to punish the perpetrator, civil litigation focuses on restitution for the survivor. It seeks to provide financial compensation for the immense suffering endured, covering costs for therapy, medical bills, lost quality of life, and the profound emotional distress that follows such abuse. This verdict forcefully tells institutions that they cannot hide from their responsibility to protect the children in their care. It establishes that a jury can and will recognize the lifelong damage caused by such abuse and hold the negligent institution financially responsible for its failures.


This outcome is a testament to the survivor's incredible courage. Coming forward after 50 years to face one’s abuser and the institution that enabled them is a monumental act of strength. This verdict honors that bravery and sends a clear message to other survivors: your voice matters, your story is valid, and it is never too late to seek justice.


The Long and Winding Road to Justice


The journey for survivors of childhood sexual abuse is often long and fraught with immense challenges. The trauma of abuse can take decades to process, and many survivors fear they won't be believed or that the legal system is stacked against them. Legal hurdles, such as the statute of limitations, have historically created significant barriers, preventing many from ever having their day in court.


At Jason J. Joy & Associates, we have seen firsthand the immense courage it takes for survivors to step forward. We are actively helping numerous survivors of childhood abuse, including those impacted by the Boy Scouts of America bankruptcy case, navigate this difficult path. We understand that even years or decades after the abuse occurred, new victims continue to come forward as they find the strength to confront their past. This New Jersey verdict is a powerful affirmation that the passage of time does not erase the harm done, nor does it diminish a survivor's right to seek justice.


Our Compassionate, No-Fee-Unless-You-Win Approach


We believe that every survivor deserves the chance to seek justice without being burdened by financial worries. That is why our firm, Jason J. Joy & Associates, operates on a contingency fee basis. When you choose our firm, there are absolutely no upfront costs to worry about. Our fee is contingent upon the successful resolution of your case, which means you only pay when we achieve a favorable outcome for you. We handle all the initial expenses related to preparing and handling your case, and you will never receive a bill for these costs. This approach allows our clients to access top-tier legal representation without any financial risk, enabling them to focus on what matters most: their healing and recovery.


Our team of experienced and compassionate attorneys understands the profound sensitivity of these cases. We know that revisiting trauma is an incredibly difficult process, and we are committed to providing a safe, confidential, and supportive environment for you to share your story. Your focus should be on your recovery; our focus is on fighting for the justice you deserve.


It's Time to Shatter the Silence


If you are a survivor of childhood sexual abuse, please know that you are not alone, and there is hope for justice. This historic verdict is proof that your story can be heard and that those responsible can be held accountable.

We urge you to take the first step. Contact Jason J. Joy & Associates for a free, confidential, and private consultation. Our compassionate team is here to listen to your story, explain your legal options, and support you every step of the way. Let us help you find your voice and fight for the justice you have long deserved.


You can reach us at (713) 221-6500 or by completing the intake form on our website.


Contact Us

By submitting this form you agree to receive text messages.

By Rebecca Rivera November 14, 2025
In this series premiere episode, Founder & President of SOSCSA, Child Sexual Abuse Survivor & BSA Bankruptcy Claimant, Curtis Garrison interviews attorney Jason J Joy for an update on the BSA bankruptcy and discussing childhood abuse litigation for which Jason is an outspoken and experienced advocate. Jason's firm is actively litigating cases for many clients his law firm represents. This podcast is recommended for clients already represented, and for those who are still contemplating coming forward to establish a claim. Topics covered in this episode: Recent BSA Bankruptcy Trust report Lajun Claimants (Guam) v. Boy Scouts of America and their recent Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari to the U.S. Supreme Court The 1.5% initial payment, possible second payment time / total percentage Future Claims, BSA Councils, BSA Charters (churches, schools, etc) which there are over 100,000 entities possibly getting free of liability Mixed Claims explained We did not vote for this plan, they promised we would be paid in “Paid in Full” Plans to file an Amicus Brief Statute of Limitations 
By Rebecca Rivera November 6, 2025
The Boy Scouts of America bankruptcy case, involving tens of thousands of survivors of childhood sexual abuse, is among the largest and most contentious mass tort proceedings in U.S. history. In this podcast, Attorney Jason Joy breaks down the latest ruling from the Third Circuit Court, which leaves many survivors of childhood sexual abuse with drastically underfunded compensation.
By Rebecca Rivera October 13, 2025
For a patient, especially one navigating the difficult journey of breast cancer treatment, trust is paramount. Trust in their doctors, trust in the treatments recommended, and trust in the medical devices designed to aid their recovery. When that trust is broken, the consequences can be devastating, leaving not just physical scars, but deep emotional and financial wounds. At Jason Joy & Associates, we believe that no one should suffer in silence due to the negligence of others. Our firm is dedicated to fighting for victims of personal injury, ensuring their voices are heard and that they receive the justice and compensation they deserve.